Filing an Extension for Your Tax Return: Pros, Cons, and Deadlines

Understanding What a Tax Extension Really Means

If you’re not ready to file your tax return by the deadline, you may be considering a tax extension. While filing
an extension can provide extra time and flexibility, it’s important to understand what an extension does—and what
it does not—before relying on one.

A tax extension gives you additional time to file your federal tax return, not additional time to pay your taxes.

By filing an extension, you receive up to six extra months to submit your completed return. However, any taxes owed
are still due by the original filing deadline. Even with an extension, failing to pay on time can result in
penalties and interest.

How to File a Tax Extension

Most individual taxpayers file an extension using IRS Form 4868. This can typically be done:

  • Electronically through tax software
  • Through a tax professional
  • By mailing the form to the IRS

To avoid penalties, it’s important to estimate your tax liability as accurately as possible and submit payment for
any amount you expect to owe when you file the extension.

Pros of Filing a Tax Extension

  1. Extra Time to Gather Documents
    An extension provides breathing room if you’re waiting on:

    • Investment or brokerage statements
    • Corrected income forms
    • Business or freelance income summaries
  2. Reduced Risk of Filing Errors
    Rushing to meet a deadline increases the likelihood of mistakes. An extension allows time to:

    • Review deductions and credits
    • Confirm income reporting
    • Avoid amended returns later
  3. More Time for Complex Tax Situations
    Taxpayers with:

    • Self-employment income
    • Investment activity
    • Multiple income sources

    often benefit from additional time to ensure accuracy.

  4. Strategic Tax Planning Opportunities
    In some cases, the extra time allows for:

    • Improved documentation of deductions
    • Professional review
    • Planning decisions that support long-term outcomes

Cons of Filing a Tax Extension

  1. Taxes Are Still Due by the Original Deadline
    An extension does not delay payment. Any unpaid balance after the deadline may be subject to:

    • Interest
    • Late payment penalties
  2. Penalties for Underpayment
    If you significantly underestimate what you owe, additional penalties may apply even if the extension was filed
    on time.
  3. Delayed Refunds
    If you’re expecting a refund, filing an extension means:

    • Your refund is delayed
    • Funds remain with the IRS longer than necessary
  4. False Sense of Security
    Some taxpayers treat extensions as a reason to postpone action entirely, which can lead to rushed filings later
    and missed planning opportunities.

Key Tax Extension Deadlines to Know

  • Original Filing Deadline: Typically mid-April
  • Extension Filing Deadline: Same as the original filing deadline
  • Extended Filing Deadline: Typically mid-October

While deadlines can shift slightly due to weekends or holidays, the six-month extension window remains consistent.

Common Misconceptions About Tax Extensions

  1. Filing an extension means you won’t owe penalties.
    Penalties and interest may still apply if taxes aren’t paid by the original deadline.
  2. Filing an extension increases audit risk.
    Filing an extension alone does not increase your chances of an audit.
  3. Only people who owe money need extensions.
    Many taxpayers file extensions simply to ensure accuracy, even if they expect a refund.

When Filing an Extension Makes Sense

An extension may be a good option if:

  • You’re missing key tax documents
  • Your tax situation is complex
  • You want professional review before filing
  • You need time to ensure accurate reporting

When an Extension May Not Be the Best Choice

You may want to file on time if:

  • You’re expecting a refund
  • Your tax situation is straightforward
  • You’ve already gathered all necessary documents

How to Avoid Issues When Filing an Extension

To minimize risk:

  • Pay as much as you reasonably can by the original deadline
  • Keep documentation organized
  • Schedule time to complete your return well before the extended deadline
  • Work with a tax professional if your situation is complex

approved by Kacy L. Allen, CPA, MAcc

Tags: